Are Your Kids Safe??

With family cruising becoming ever more popular and the bigger ships having multiple pools and even mini water parks, how safe are your children? Until recently most cruise lines have left the responsibility up to parents, with some tragic results. there have been several incidents over the tears of children drowning on cruise ships. So what’s new?

Norwegian Cruise Lines  indicated recently that it will first employ lifeguards on its largest ships, including the Norwegian Epic, Norwegian Escape, Norwegian Getaway and Norwegian Breakaway.

NCL says that for the last several years it employed what it called “pool monitors” to supervise swimming pools on certain of its ships. These individuals, however, were not certified in advanced life-saving training by the American Red Cross.

Disney Cruises has hired lifeguards for the past several years, following a near drowning of a 4 year old boy which caused significant brain injury and eventually led to a multi-million settlement for the lifetime medical needs of the child.

Royal Caribbean became the second cruise line to hire lifeguards when it announced two months ago that it would abandon its ill-conceived swim-at-your-own-risk policy which led to numerous drownings and near drownings on Royal Caribbean ships.  I noticed on Independence when I cruised last year that they had life vests by the towel station, but never saw one being used. Their H2o zone on the Freedom Class ships, which has a series of paddling pools and water toys also had a very deep pool right beside it which always concerned me. Last year they put a false floor in to make it shallow, a good move in my opinion.

In the past several years, several children drowned in swimming pools on NCL ships:

Two years ago, a 10-year-old girl drowned in a swimming pool aboard  NCL Norwegian Gem.

In February 2014, two small children were pulled from a pool on NCL’s  Norwegian Breakaway as the cruise ship was sailing from New York to the Bahamas. Both children were unresponsive. The younger child (age 4) died on the cruise ship. The other child (age 6) was medevaced by the Coast Guard.

Following the drowning on the Norwegian Gem, a woman on the cruise who witnessed what she described a “truly horrifying scene” with her family, started a petition to convince NCL to hire lifeguards.

There has never been a public consensus regarding this issue, at least among people who pay for cruises. The majority of people responding to articles about children drowning in cruise ship swimming pools quickly attack the parents. Other readers selfishly voice petty concerns that they do not want to pay higher cruise fares if the cruise companies pass the costs of hiring lifeguards along to their guests.

The hard-core cruise fan site Cruise Critic asked its readers after Royal Caribbean adopted its new lifeguard policy:  “Do you think cruise ships should have lifeguards?” Only a little over 30% said “Yes, you can’t be too careful,” with around 20% saying that lifeguards should be employed only “on ships aimed at families.” 40% of the Cruise Critic readers said “No, it’s not their responsibility,” which seems heartless considering how many children have died on cruise ships without lifeguards.

So congratulations to NCL for joining Disney and Royal Caribbean as the only cruise lines with a demonstrated commitment to trying to keep children, and other guests, safe around pools at sea. Hopefully, others will eventually follow suit. What do you think?

Dee