Taylor - Answered a Question by Henderson (01 Oct 08 10:58)

The usual rubbish whenever the question of tipping comes up. You only have to read the answers so far to see just how ridiculous this tipping business really is! Trite phrases such as "For your conenience" and "part of the tradition of cruising" appear with monotonous regularity. Well I've got news for you - I am an adult and it is definitely NOT convenient for me to be told how much and to who I should give a tip before I even board the ship. No-one has yet answered a question I always ask - Is it just the two or three people on the ship that you tip that are poorly paid. Of course not! The guy who cleans the toilets helps to make your holiday experience pleasuable but when does he ever get a tip? The answer is simple - there are several cruise lines in which tips are prepaid - book with those if you don't like the nonsensical ritual of tipping at the end of each cruise.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
John - replied to Taylor (01 Oct 08 17:41)

Taylor of Loughborough. The question "Is it just the two or three people on the ship that you tip that are poorly paid" has to be answered with no. Although not nearly experienced cruisers as some we have found some of the best service to come from those who are not recipients of the pre cruise tips.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
middleton - Answered a Question by Henderson (30 Sep 08 21:11)

Costa do not let you opt out of the auto tip.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
mcdermott - replied to middleton (01 Oct 08 06:17)

Tipping is part of cruising and part of the wages of the staff.So pay and be happy or dont travel.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
christopher middleton - replied to mcdermott (01 Oct 08 23:09)

I was replying to the question asked not giving a opinion on the rights & wrongs of the question, can you do not understand the difference .

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Blyth - Answered a Question by Henderson (30 Sep 08 21:17)

Yes you can opt out, but tipping is part of the tradition of cruising where you reward those who really look after you. We nowadays pay before we even join the ship and never had any poor service yet but if the occassion did arise then you can deal with that issue with the Purser's office, but have to agree all the staff take exceptional good care of us and they were worth every penny/dollar/euro.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Aldrich - Answered a Question by Henderson (30 Sep 08 21:34)

For your convenience Costa has introduced an automatic tipping system, so instead of worrying how much and when to tip, an amount of 6 Euro, or US$8 per person per day will be added to your on board account. mandatory service charge for all passengers that is added to the cruise account and cannot be removed or changed. Costa UK managing director Marco Rosa said the fixed charge was brought in because unions were unhappy with the optional tipping system. “Each page in the brochure has a table that shows clearly the cost of the service charge so we are upfront about it.” Although the charge is compulsory, Rosa said Costa did not want to include it in the cruise price as it would make the line uncompetitive. It would also be confusing for the trade as Costa does not pay commission on the charge. So the answer is 'No' - you cannot remove the tips on Costa.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
morris - Answered a Question by Henderson (30 Sep 08 21:48)

As previously stated you are not allowed to remove this charge...I would just add that when we went earlier this year if your cruise was longer than 8 days the charge was reduced to 4.50 euros per day per person. In our opinion this should just be added to the cost of the cruise which was how we dealt with it...I have to say that the staff on the cruise we went on did not give good service (apart from our cabin steward and waitress) and we felt that if there was an incentive i.e. optional tips, perhaps they would have tried a bit harder!!!!

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Neil & Ida Down - replied to morris (30 Sep 08 22:15)

I'm sorry that you had bad or inadequate service but the fault does not normally lie with the lack of incentive but with the ship's management. So many of the ships I have been on have been really happy ships and the way the staff were treated and managed had a huge amount to do with this. Neil.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report

Daily Top 10 Deals

  • Shanghai, Hong Kong & Ho Chi Minh City

    Royal Caribbean - Mariner of the Seas - P13225 - 29 Aug 17 - 17nts

    Fly Shanghai : Xiamen : Hong Kong (Overnight) : Ho Chi Minh City (Phu My) : Singapore : Kuala Lumpur : Penang : Phuket : Singapore : Fly UK

    Now from £1599pp Was £1999pp

    • 2 Night Hotel Stay in Central Shanghai
    • FREE Shanghai City Tour Included!
    • All Flights & Overseas Transfers

    View More Tailor Made Cruises >>


  • Beaches of Bali with the Best of Vietnam, Thailand and Hong Kong

    Celebrity Cruises - Celebrity Millennium - T15902 - 14 Jan 18 - 22nts

    Fly UK to Bali (Overnight – 5nt Hotel Stay) : Fly Singapore (1nt Hotel Stay) : Singapore (Overnight) : Bangkok (Overnight) : Ho Chi Minh City (Phu My) : Hue/Danang : Hanoi (Overnight) : Hong Kong (Overnight) : Fly UK

    Now from £1899pp Was £2399pp

    • 5 Night Hotel Stay in Bali with B&B 
    • 1 Night 5* Hotel Stay in Singapore with B&B
    • Overnight Stays in Bangkok, Hanoi & Hong Kong

    View More Celebrity Tailor Made Holidays >


  • Hamburg, Copenhagen & Amsterdam

    Cruise & Maritime - Magellan - 1 Oct 2017 - 9nts

    London Tilbury : Amsterdam : Hamburg (overnight) at sea Copenhagen (overnight) Aalborg (Denmark) : London Tilbury

    Now from £499pp Was 1239

    • The Cheapest Cruise From Southampton you will see 
    • Limited Cabins Available

    Click to view all Cruise & Maritime 2017 >

Show More Deals