Latest Photos![]() ![]() |
Comment
by Kennedy, Dublin (10 Oct 08 22:29)
about
this REVIEW
I was on the Island Escape in 2007 and I'm sorry to say it was the worst cruise of my life. The ports were great, the food and ship left a lot to be desired - poor housekeeping in the cabins and the beachcomber was a mess - really not a fit place to eat food. The pool area was shoddy and the glass (perspex) enclosed stairway up to the lookout (or whatever it was called) leaked when it rained. Island Cruises never really got going as a cruise company - casual does not mean shoddy. I have heard that the Island Star is a better ship (and better run ship) so its a pity it is not the one that goes to Thomson's. I have cruised on several of the Thomson ships (including the much lamented Topaz and (soon to be gone) Emerald. Thomson know how to run a cruise company - Island never got it right. Standards on the Island Escape could not have been lower. I accept that people on cruises on the IE enjoyed themselves but that must have been in spite of the ship, not because of her. First time cruisers may have had a great time but they had nothing to compare it with. I love budget cruising because I travel alone and single supplements can be very steep. However, with a good early booking deal, I have managed to cruise on several mid market ships for less than I paid for the Island Escape and with higher standards.
Report this comment
Comment
by mcguire, dunfermline fife (10 Oct 08 09:20)
about
this REVIEW
hi ya mr or mrs sparrow of wiltshire im i reading right here so no cruises will be running during summer next year at all with isaland on escape .i know cruises will still go a head up in till march 2009 .where did you get info are you just back off cruise.with thompson cause you state you cruised with island in april.many thanks for more info
Report this comment
Comment
by ferguson, gillingham (10 Oct 08 11:58)
about
a COMMENT by mcguire (10 Oct 08 09:20)
Its all a bit confusing but surely Island escape will sail under that brand next summer Then the Island Escape will change to Thomson colors in October? Meanwhile Thomsons have developed a new casual cruise concept which must be using one of their existing ships. It seems to me that the difference between Thomsons and Island is casual style cruising does not have a formal restaurant, if so it would be easy to convert the formal restaurant to a buffet and save a load of money on the waiters!
Still confused though.
Report this comment
Comment
by sparrow, wiltshire (10 Oct 08 10:48)
about
a COMMENT by mcguire (10 Oct 08 09:20)
Hello
nope I have never cruised with Thomson, I have only ever cruised with Island, Its devastating but true that muched loved Island cruises will cease to exist after october 09 when the island escape will be absorbed into the Thomson fleet, Island star will sail the Caribbean until march 09 all cruises on the island star after that date including the Caribbean Journey cruise back to Palma on 26/03/09 are cancelled.....so there will be no cruises with Island on the star or the escape after october 09, news & press releases are available on websites like travelmole & cruisecritic and news on the island star cancellations are on the thomson website http://www.thomson.co.uk/cruise/island-cruises.html
Report this comment
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||


















