Disappointing for a single passenger

 
Reviewed By: Paxton, Ayrshire on 29th Jul 2010
Cruise Line: Fred. Olsen Cruises Times cruised before: 1-2
Cruise Ship: Boudicca Sailed: June, 2010
Destination: Mediterranean Age: 65+
Cabin: Outside Occasion: Birthday
This is a review booked that I booked for my mother in law - unfortunately the cruise was not good for two main reasons. Firstly the most annoying aspect was the cabin being unsuitable due to engine noise and extreme vibration. My mother in law complained immediately but was told the cruise was full with no alternative cabins. However she spoke to another passenger who had experienced exactly the same problem, but they were accommodated into a better cabin albeit having had to pay for the privilege.

Secondly the Dining arrangements were far from satisfactory, Mary was seated with 3 other people ( Mother, Father & Daughter) at a table for 4. This was acceptable until the family dined elsewhere, on quite a few occasions this left Mary totally alone.

This cruise was an 80th Birthday treat or should have been. Given the cost of this cruise, we would have expected much better accommodation and certainly a more sympathetic response to her complaint. Also a greater awareness of an 80 year old lady having to sit on her own, feeling completely isolated.

In conclusion we feel really angry that this situation was allowed to happen, and more incensed that nothing was done to remedy it.
Quality of Foodn/a
Entertainmentn/a
Shore Excursionsn/a
Staffn/a
Children's Facilitiesn/a
Onboard Activitiesn/a
Cabinsn/a
Overall Ratingn/a
Was this review informative to you?

Comment by mcnally, Skelmersdale (27 Aug 10 19:03) about this REVIEW
What is happening here to good customer service ! your mother in law requested help and you say , none was given, this is not putting F.O. in a social service position....ITS just Good Service, this is no diffrence to going into a shop buying something when you get home and unwrap it it isnt the same as in shop window, buying a meal not much taste or going to a show and finding a large post spoils my view....The lady says she asked...bet she didn't shout and make a big fuss !....if it was my relation i would be angry too. Joanie Mc Lancashire.
Comment by Wright, coventry (06 Aug 10 21:30) about this REVIEW
I totally agree with you. If a cruise line accepts bookijngs from single passengers than they should look after them, especially as they pay more! I am not saying they have to check they are mixing with other pax but at least give them the opportunity to do so by arranging get togethers etc. It is not a lot of work to arrange and a lot of lines do this. I am sure FO specialise in this as they usually have a lot of singles. Maybe it was one of those cruises when not many singles were on board but it couldn´t have been much fun for her. Perhaps next time she could try Saga as there are bound to be may people in the same situation. Hope it has not put her off,
Comment by Wood, Cambuslang (06 Aug 10 21:43) about a COMMENT by Wright (06 Aug 10 21:30)
FO provides the facility for single travellers to get together but Mr Paxton doesn't say if his Mother in law took advantage of this. As you say it is not up to FO to make passengers participate. It is unfortunate that Mr Paxton's Mother in law felt isolated. I have been on lots of cruises and always found a lot of people to speak to and have moved tables when dining arrangements required it. Never a problem with finding dining companions. But you do need to put a bit of effort into it. It isn;t easy if you are shy.
Comment by kendall, Newcastle on tyne (30 Jul 10 10:08) about this REVIEW
Several comments. 1: It looks like your accom was what you had paid for i.e. inside /lower cabin if noisy. Obviously if no cabins available then no chance but perhaps she could have moved to other passengers cabin or was that even noisier!!!??? 2: Is your mother a fit 80 year old. If so could she not have asked to be moved and or requested a sitting at a bigger tale initially. 3: If not then surely it was asking a lot for the cruise company to act as carer and to GUESS that she was unhappy on her own. Sorry to sound harsh but ships are not social services and if she was unhappy then she should let staff know.
Comment by paxton, ayrshire (05 Aug 10 11:37) about a COMMENT by kendall (30 Jul 10 10:08)
1.) Why have you assumed that the cabin was "inside/lower", presumably on the basis that it was noisy? Even more unacceptable when we book an outside higher deck cabin! 2.) Yes she is a fit 80 year old, dresses herself, washes herself and can cover a mile in fairly prompt time, all in all a capable and independant lady. She even managed to ask for help with a less conspicuous table or being moved to another table with other singkle passengers. No resolution was forthcoming from FO staff! 3.) We take great exception to your Social Services comment, based on the comments we made you have made massive leaps of assumptions with absolutely no knowledge of the person or the facts. In summary we stand by our posting. FO did nothing to remedy the situations stated.
Comment by North, Huddersfield (30 Jul 10 21:35) about a COMMENT by kendall (30 Jul 10 10:08)
I agree with your points - whilst I am sorry this lady had a cruise that was not enjoyable I do not think the blame can be put on Fred Olsen. The dining situation she could have resolved herself - it is not Olsen's job to provide this level of support but if there was a request in the dining room I am sure they would have tried to accomodate if possible .
Comment by paxton, ayrshire (05 Aug 10 11:43) about a COMMENT by North (30 Jul 10 21:35)
Suggest that you read the reponse we have given to the above. Who is to blame? My mother in law, who tried to get another cabin and table or FO for ignoring her requests.
Comment by kendall, Newcastle on tyne (06 Aug 10 09:10) about a COMMENT by paxton (05 Aug 10 11:43)
So did she try the other passengers cabin and was it noisier. Most "complaints " on here (not yourself of course) are from people who have booked beer money cabins and expect champagne service.. I of course accept that this was one of the first ever high cabins that was noisy. Equally I am sure that if she is that independent after first night alone she should have gone to guest relations and got it sorted. All previous comments re FO are always that they are very helpful.
Comment by North, Huddersfield (05 Aug 10 22:47) about a COMMENT by paxton (05 Aug 10 11:43)
To answer your question on the limited facts that you chose to present :- Your mother in law
Comment by Wood, Cambuslang (29 Jul 10 20:33) about this REVIEW
I do feel sorry for your Mother in law to have been placed in a noisy cabin but, unfortunately, if the ship is full or she cannot pay then there is nothing that can be done. It is all part of cruising. It shouldn't have been the responsibility of the other family to ensure your mother in law didn't dine alone. They were on holiday and entitled to eat wherever they liked without having to feel guilty. Your mother in law could have asked the maitre'd for another table on these evenings. I think it is unfair of you to expect FO to assume responsibility either - if nobody says anything they wont know. If you felt that your mother in law was going to be isolated it may have been better if a family member or a friend accompanied her. Or she could have attended the Single Passengers get together and she may have met some other single travellers.

Write a Cruise Review
Receive a FREE copy
of Fodor's
Complete
Guide to
European
Cruises


Live Prices
(65350) (32480) (32372) (14140) (1448)