Cruise News

Cruise death may change Scots law

 

Colin Love, from Maryhill, was a keen traveller and was on a cruise when he tragically drowned
Colin Love, from Maryhill, was a keen traveller and was on a cruise when he tragically drowned

The tragic death of a Glasgow student who drowned while on a holiday cruise could bring

about a change in the law of Scotland.

 

Colin Love, 23, from Maryhill, drowned in treacherous seas off Margarita Island in the Caribbean.

It would appear to have been a tragic accident, but eight months on from his death a loop-hole in Scots law has left his loved-ones without any final answers as to how it happened.

As it stands, the Crown Office, which is in charge of investigating deaths in Scotland, has no authority to look into the deaths of Scots abroad, unlike in England where a coroner can investigate deaths overseas.

 

Colin's friend Dr Kenneth Faulds is leading a campaign to change the law. He is taking his fight to Holyrood and is preparing a petition to go before an influential committee of MSPs.

Colin's mum Julie, 41, said: "This isn't going to help me, but hopefully it will help others in this situation. I wouldn't want any other family to go through what we went through.

"A German tourist who saw what happened told me he went back to the beach where Colin was pulled ashore, hours after it happened, to lay some flowers. When he got there, Colin's body was still lying there on a sun lounger. It's really distressing.

"We need to have a way that the Scottish authorities can check that all the proper procedures were gone through."

Dr Faulds, 23, said: "It's absolutely amazing that this is the state of the law in Scotland.

"Colin's mum has still not heard anything official from the Foreign and Commonwealth Office about how her son died.

"It was left to the friend who Colin was on holiday with to tell her.

"The Foreign Office didn't help repatriate his body, Colin's mum had to pay to have it brought home to Scotland.

"We want answers to why the cruise line allowed people to swim in those waters but the Crown Office cannot investigate."

Dr Faulds' petition will be formally lodged with the Scottish Parliament on September 1.

 

This article was taken from the Glasgow Evening Times, with thanks

 

 

COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE
Comment by dona, both (02 Sep 09 16:56) about this ARTICLE
How awful and distressing for his family. Did the cruise line not do anything to help the family or Colin? Was he on a cruise trip? I wish you every success in your goal.
Comment by Hood, Blyth (02 Sep 09 11:01) about this ARTICLE
It is not up to the Government to pay for repatriation - this is what you pay your travel insurance for - my father died 15 years ago in Tenerife and there was no problem the Insurance Company paid and sorted it all out.
Comment by Taylor, Farnham (02 Sep 09 09:31) about this ARTICLE
Why on earth should he government pay to repatriate this man's body. And as for the cruise line allowing/or not allowing passengers to swim in the waters, he was a 23 year old. He can make his own decisions as he did. There's too much blame culture these days. Is it too much to accept that it was possibly a tragic accident.
Comment by Appleby, Durban South Africa (02 Sep 09 08:29) about this ARTICLE
It is awful when something like this happens and one can only feel for the family. But what has the cruise line got to do with it, he was shoreside not on the ship..........they have no control over where or when he swims and they surely cannot be responsible for telling him which beach he can or cannot go on.
Comment by Phillips, Gourock (02 Sep 09 09:08) about a COMMENT by Appleby (02 Sep 09 08:29)
I would totally agree with "Appleby's" comments. a tragic accident. Why must so many people today to look for someone to blame. As he said we can't have cruise companies telling passengers what they can and can't do when ashore. Some advise is normally given to people who choose to go to the talks about the ports,but these are not obligatory. You can't have the cruise companies responsible for what happens ashore, will it be the cruise companies responsibility next if someone gets pickpocketed, knifed, etc etc. Will we be told where we can and can't eat? What we should and shouldn't drink , how many units of alcohol, to wear suitable footwear , put our suntan lotion , raincoat on etc etc................. We must all take responsibility for our own actions. If we want to swim, ask, or look and see where the locals are swimming.

Add a COMMENT about     Ask a QUESTION about     ANSWER  Question