Lonton - Answered a Question by swift (24 May 08 12:51)

Sympathise with your admirably independant streak, but I woudl guess that most lines instist on a carer, not because you need one day to day, but in case of emergency evacuation - their rules/insurers/whatever probably insist on it. This may explain their stance.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
O'Hanlon, - Answered a Question by swift (24 May 08 08:26)

Dear Messers Swift, Your query concerning concerning "carers" raises logistical issues. I cruised the Pacific Ocean to Hawaii recently on the Diamond Princess (Princess Cruises. There were many wheelchair users on the cruise and all had carers. I was enormously impressed by the help, kindness, and curtesy of the ships officers and crew toward wheelchair users and carers. But I have to say that a ship being a ship and the sea being the sea, carers are necessary. Ships have to have strong and safe doors; gangways must be secure; access to theatre seats must be convenient. Indeed, there is a host of occasions where a carers is essential. I wonder if this is your first cruise and whether you have considered the limitations of access that of necessity occurs by the very contraints of safe sea travel. I hope you both have an enjoyable experience. Joseph.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
hastings - Answered a Question by swift (24 May 08 09:50)

I am in exactly the same boat(pardon the pun)but have the same problem. although i usually go with my sister or friend i too am independant. it is really wrong. do they say those who get inebriated must get some-one to take them to their cabin? no; i think its discrimination. although i can see it from the cruise lines side, people with two legs also find it difficult when the sea is rough. as with all things, you know your own limitations.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Leyser - Answered a Question by swift (24 May 08 14:32)

You need to challenge these companies as I honestly believe they are breaking the law - intially ask for their reasons and challenge that you only have a wheelchair and while using your wheelchair you do not leave your brain behind. Also you could ask why the companies you do use why they do not discriminate that would give you an edge to your challenge to other companies If this is unsuccessful I think asking your MP to investigate their reasons behind such foolish policies will expose and stop such discrimination. Good Luck. Debbie Leyser.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Kelly - Answered a Question by swift (25 May 08 16:29)

Since loss of my leg I have been a wheelchair user, OK I can walk on the false one for short distances but normally in the wheelchair. On a cruise without my partner how would I manage up and down the steps from the ship to dock, etc. What would happen if there was a problem with the ship, how would I manage if I was not well, the list could go on. If you use a wheelchair you need a carer as you cannot rely on the goodwill of the crew all the time. Sorry I am not more supportive but being a wheelchair myself, having done a few cruises I would say however independent you are you need assistance. Bo.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Godfrey - Answered a Question by swift (25 May 08 23:05)

Interesting post! agree! a carer NHS.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Davies - Answered a Question by swift (26 May 08 07:58)

We have cruised on 5 occasions and not once needed any assistance. We choose our ships within the two cruise lines that will allow us to travel very carefully (Berlitz guide). We read the ratings and chart that tells us about the accessibility. In an emergency situation (god forbid) with the best will in the world if a carer needs to get a wheelchair user to the muster station from a different floor with lifts out of action it's not going to happen. When are people going to wake up and stop putting disabled people into a bracket that they shouldnt have a life and travel. Cruising is the best option for wheelchair users. I thank people for the positive comments. I would like to a wider choice of cruises and will continue to cruise.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report

Daily Top 10 Deals

  • EXCLUSIVE RATES! No Fly Paris, Amsterdam & Belgium

    MSC Cruises- Magnifica - 08 Oct 2018 - 7nts

    Southampton : Paris (Le Havre) : Zeebrugge (Belgium) : Amsterdam : Hamburg : Southampton

    Now from 455pp Was 713pp

    • Ex-UK Cruising for Just £65pp per day
    • All Meals & Entertainment on Board
    • All Inclusive Drinks Rates Also Available

    View All 2018 MSC Cruises From Southampton

  • EXCLUSIVE! World's Biggest Ship from Barcelona to Rome

    Royal Caribbean - Symphony of the Seas - 10 Jun 2018 - 4nts

    Barcelona : Palma de Mallorca : Marseille : Florence/Pisa (La Spezia) : Rome (Civitavecchia)

    Now from £619pp

    • Includes Return Flights & Transfers from London
    • Regional Flights Available from Birmingham, Bristol, Manchester, Edinburgh, Glasgow or Cardiff*

    View all Symphony of the Seas Sailings >

  • No Fly British Isles & Scottish Highlands

    MSC Cruises - MSC Magnifica - 03 September 2018 - 10nts

    Southampton : Paris (Le Havre) : South Queensferry : Invergordon : Newcastle : Amsterdam : Hamburg : Southampton

    Now from £769pp

    • FREE Coach Transfers to Southampton from 20 Regional Pick Up Points 
    • All Inclusive Restaurant & Drinks Package 
    • Available April 18 -  Oct 18

    View Our Top 10 MSC Cruise Deals >>

Show More Deals

New Rules re Drinks Packages on RCI

The Palmers, EPPING -

Celebrity to introduce Marmite on the...

annie, Glasgow -

Norovirus and Prevention

Haworth, Wokingham -

Wilba, The Emirates and Beyond.

Wilba -

Why always us

George, Gateshead (3) -

Wilba, The Emirates and Mauritius

Wilba -

Ive been away for a while

MarkB, Woodbridge UK -

My 4th Cruise

MarkB, Woodbridge UK -

I'm backing Britain (or thought I was)

Old Sea Dog, Stockport -

Lake Cruising

Mariers2, Rushden -

View More From The Forum