Mellon - replied to Neil & Ida Down (02 Mar 09 18:14)

I disagree with OV policy to stop people smoking in their cabins. I detest the smell of alcohol will they 'ban' this in public places - no I think not. Having read many reviews you seem to be the only one who says they can smell it as "it came though into your cabin" - I dont think so. So I am afraid I disagee with your comments on this matter.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Neil & Ida Down - replied to Mellon (03 Mar 09 14:22)

I appreciate that you have your on views on this subject but I can assure you that not only the smell but the actual smoke did come into our cabin fron the one next to us. The other thing that is worth thinking about is that it is not just the occupants of the cabin who are immersed in smoke but also the two cabin staff who serviced it and they couldn't complain to the management but I can assure you that they did speak to me about it and to subject anyone to that abuse is outlawed in the UK and is gradually being outlawed throughout the cruise networks. I still feel that in ten years time people will have accepted smoking as bad and wonder how we ever put up with it. .... Neil.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
mellon - replied to Neil & Ida Down (04 Mar 09 14:34)

As you say everyone is entitled to their opinion - you have yours and I have mine. The cabin crew smoke as well you know!!!! People do accept that smoking is bad for you I am sure. Very strong views you have on the subject which you are entitled to just as I am. I do think your views are a bit exaggerated though! I mean immersed in smoke a bit strong I think. It never bothers me anyway as I only smoke on my balcony as we are allowed to do. Marie.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Foz - replied to Neil & Ida Down (05 Mar 09 09:26)

Hello Neil & Ida, I agree with your views completely. On our last cruise where smoking was banned in cabins, I could smell cigarette smoke every time we walked through the corridor. I have medical problems where fumes of any kind are dangerous to my health and I imagine , I am not the only person suffering contamination because of some selfish individuals. Smoking on balconies can also cause problems for non-smoking people.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
hale - Answered a Question by Speight (09 Feb 09 16:28)

Hi,Been on both OV ships several times & never had a problem with stale smoke smells. (none smokers).

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Winifred Walsh - Answered a Question by Speight (09 Feb 09 23:56)

I have been cruising since 1980 along with my husband, sister and her husband. We are in our mid 70's now, non smokers, and can honestly say we have never entered a cabin and smelt stale smoke. Nor have we smelt smoke from adjoining cabins during our cruises. Neil & Ida Down??? sound like mischief makers and I suggest Speight you take no notice of them and have a lovely cruise. Winifred.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Fielding - replied to Winifred Walsh (05 Mar 09 08:15)

Hope you've read my reply to Speight's question as I have replied to it with a truthful answer and I wouldn't like you to doubt it and call me a 'mischief maker'. I wouldn't want to put Speight off but you can only write about your own experience.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Neal - Answered a Question by Speight (10 Feb 09 00:00)

My lady is an anti-smoking bloodhound, & she's never detected any traces in a (non- balcony) cabin on a number of cruises with OV. Neil's update is useful, but he fails to clarify that his comments don't refer to OV, he's never sailed with them. Chris.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Neil & Ida Down - replied to Neal (05 Mar 09 10:32)

Hi Chris, In a way you are incorrect. True I have never sailed with Ocean Village but I have been on Ocean Village when she was Star Princess but the remark I made was about smoke intruding into the cabin concerned Constellation but can apply to many ships, particularly those with connecting doors. Hope you are enjoying your cruise an look forward to your return. .......Neil.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
cox - Answered a Question by Speight (28 Feb 09 01:12)

We are just back from this ship and I never smelt smoke in the cabin .

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report

Daily Top 10 Deals

  • PRICE DROP - Rotterdam, Bruges & Paris!

    P&O - Oceana - 3 Jan 19 - 7nts

    Southampton : Rotterdam : Bruges (Zeebrugge) : Paris (Le Havre) : Cherbourg : Southampton

    Now from £388pp

    • Only £1pp Deposit Needed to Book Your Stateroom Today!*
    • Cruise From Only £55pp per night!

    Click To View All P&O 2018 Cruises > 


  • FLASH SALE! 5* No Fly Scandinavia & Baltics

    Celebrity Cruises - Celebrity Silhouette - 7 Jul 2018 - 14nts

    Southampton : Bruges : Copenhagen : Stockholm : Tallinn : St. Petersburg (Overnight) : Berlin (Rostock) Southampton

    Now from £899pp

    • LAST FEW CABINS REMAINING
    • Includes All Meals & Entertainment
    • Cruise From Just £71pp Per Night

    View More Celebrity Cruises From Southampton >>


  • 5* Transatlantic Cruising With New York, Miami & New Orleans

    Celebrity Silhouette - 03 November 2018 - 19nts

    Southampton : Boston : New York (Overnight) : Bermuda : Bahamas : Fort Launderdale : (1 Night Hotel Stay South Beach Miami) Fly To New Orleans (3 Nights Central Hotel Stay) : Fly Uk

    Now from £1949pp

    • 15 Nights 5* Modern Luxury Cruising Onboard Celebrity Silhouette
    • 3 Nights Central Hotel Stay In New Orleans
    • Includes Return Flight & All Overseas Transfers

    View Full Detailed Itinerary>>

Show More Deals
Julia Rhodes's blog

Im going on Independence of the Seas!

By Julia Rhodes

 As you read this blog post, I will be heading down to Southampton to board the Royal Caribbean Independence of the Seas for a 2night mini cruise over to Le Havre!I booked this cruise as a treat for my other half and little boy who is 4.5yrs old. He knows what mommy does for a job and has really wanted to go on a ‘big ship’ like mommy does. He is super excited and counting down the sleeps!The Indy is currently undergoing a refit to add on some amazing new things to bring it u...

Read More

May 15 2018 11:00:39:000AM


Jills Guide To Rivers Part Deux

By Jill Johnson

Jill Johnson's blog

 My second installment on River Cruising, for people who would like to try something new & looking for help and information. I am pleased to help. Here are some brief details of some of the Tour Operators I deal with on a regular basis, along with transport options Rail, Flight, Coach there is something for everyone.Maybe you dont like flying or due to health you are not able to fly, well all is not lost you can opt for Coach or Rail – the journey is longer but imagine all th...

Read More

May 16 2018 06:00:00:000AM

Fred Olsen and me! A match mad...

By Holly Crabtree

Holly Crabtree's blog

After recently returning form a 6 day adventure to the Fjords on Fred Olsen Balmoral it is easy to see why people have such affectionate things to say about them. Many of my colleagues feel the same way regarding Fred Olsen. It is just the feel of the ship when you embark it just feels like you are back home. Maybe this has something to do with the smaller ships so much more personal and so much more warmth than the larger ships.I sailed from Newcastle which was fab for me living in Leeds , o...

Read More

May 15 2018 07:11:50:000AM