BLYTH - Answered a Question by Taylor (08 Sep 08 13:33)

When you check-in ask then if not then, then go to the Purser's office and they will delete the charge by giving you a cabin credit if you have paid this at the time of booking then you can deal with the tips as you wish by cash on the last night.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Ian - replied to BLYTH (08 Sep 08 15:27)

You're going to have a very busy last night running round to find all the waiters that served you through the cruise! Your suggestion only really works on the traditional dining lines - when I always remove the charge from my account and pay by cash. I wouldn't do it on NCL though - they're very clear that it's a service charge and it's contractual (not a recommendation as on other lines).

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
BLYTH - replied to Ian (09 Sep 08 09:01)

I don't agree with the issue raised by Mr Taylor he posed a question and the answer given. I agree with the up front approach I have not yet found on the cruises we have been on that we have had any problems with any service. However on the last night you are only dealing with your cabin staff; waiter/assistant in the main diningroom where you ate and the Mairtre'd and they are all easy to find. The other waiters in the bars; pool areas etc all see their tip with the 15% service charge added to the cost of your drinks/purchases. I agree tipping is part of the trend set by our American passengers, but I would rather see the staff paid a fair wage but then the cost of cruisng would rise beyond many peoples pockets particularly with the current credit squeeze. The reason many lines have introduced autobilling on tips is so many passengers and the British are regarded by many as the worst for not tipping, but others may disgree.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Ian - replied to BLYTH (09 Sep 08 10:58)

I totally agree with the bit about fair wages, but sadly that's not going to happen any time soon. As I say, on other lines your suggested approach is fine. But on NCL you are very unlikely to have the same waiter every night.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
BLYTH - replied to Ian (10 Sep 08 08:21)

I agree, but the Chair of NCL did say I think in 2007 that he felt they should be waged but the other cruise lines were not prepared to support the idea. Their Freestyle approach makes that statement difficult to believe given as you say you rarely see the same waiter so autobilling for tips would seem much unfairer on the staff than you dealing direct with them at the end of your cruise.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Bothwell - replied to BLYTH (08 Oct 08 23:37)

If i have prepaid these fees up front then how do any of the staff know that i have ....as i dont wanting to be paying twice.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
BLYTH - replied to Bothwell (25 Oct 08 13:19)

They will be advised you have opted for this, so they know come the last night their envelope will just be a formal card saying unless you add a bit to the card and perhaps if service was exceptional you might want to add a bit extra cash, they can't afford not to offer good service as their work is evaluated and if not up to scratch they will not see their contract renewed.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Wilba - replied to BLYTH (09 Sep 08 11:05)

Hi! If I can pick up on your last couple of lines of comment! I fail to see the commonly quoted argument of paying the staff a fair wage would put the cost of cruising out of reach of the masses. The cruise companies want $10 a day off us to pay the staffs wages. Put that into the ticket price & it's hardly noticeable on the cruise cost. Don't mention service charges, tipping or any other charges, & everyone of their staff would be better off because no one is bucking the system, a more importantly no one is telling 'us' how & whom to give 'our' money to. If anyone can give me a good reason why A: It would not work & B: Why it should increase the cost of cruising by more than £40 a week max.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
BLYTH - replied to Wilba (10 Sep 08 08:17)

The current earnings they get from the cruise company is around $3,000 per year plus their tips and the reason autobilling is coming in is because many don't tip. If they were to be paid a fair wage then the $3,000 figure would have to to up to $20,000 and that is only £11,000 per year, put these equations into the costs and not difficult to see how they would soar. The fact they will work for $3,000 plus tips is a reflection on them and the fact many of their costs are met by the cruise line like food and laundry to name two and the fact they don't get much in the way of time off to spend any monies they get. One advert I came across suggested earning including tips would be hoped to be in the region of $24,000, but I doubt that would be an average but it does highlight the idea that the costs could be high but again all statistics !!

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Wilba - replied to BLYTH (10 Sep 08 14:57)

Sorry to go on about this but I really feel you, along with others are missing the picture here. The cruise lines want $10 a day off us to pay the staff wages. If a cabin stew gets the recommended $3.50 a day x 2 person per cabin = $7 a day x 7 days a week = $49 x 16 cabins he cleans a day = $784 x 40 working weeks a year = $31360 + $3000 basic pay = $34,360 per annum. This is lottery money in their homelands, it’s the stuff dreams are made of & this has been achieved by simply adding in $10 a day into the cruise ticket price. How can this possibly make the ticket price soar. If I’m missing something here please advise me accordingly.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Pippa Hayden's blog

All Aboard The Caribbean Princess

By Pippa Hayden

So last week was a pretty busy week for me. Living up in Lossiemouth I had a training course in Glasgow on Wednesday and a training course in Edinburgh on Thursday but the highlight of my week has to have been my Ship visit onboard the Caribbean Princess. She was in port in Invergordon for the day whilst on her 12 night British Isles itinerary so I took the chance to hop onboard and see what she had to offer.When I arrived I was greeted in the Piazza by John from Princess Cruise and some othe...

Read More

May 21 2017 08:43:18:000AM


Lovely Eclipse Weekend

By Lee Johnson

Lee Johnson's blog

I have just had a fantastic 2 night cruise on the wonderful Eclipse.The mini cruise was part of my month long 40th Celebrations and was a little getaway for me and my partner. It is the first time in 14 years that we have been away without the children and although we missed them we had such a great few days.We started the break by heading down to Southampton, which is a bit of a trek from Barrow-in-Furness but I find it no problem by rail. I would recommend staying over in Southampton the ...

Read More

May 22 2017 07:56:28:000PM

Silversea was not meant to be!

By Barbara Hopley

Barbara Hopley's blog

On Monday 22 May I was booked to go on a ship visit of the ‘Silver Whisper’ by Silversea Cruises. We get invited to see ships all the time but do them on our days off as too busy to take time out of a working week. That’s how dedicated I am to see as many ships as possible as so much easier to sell when you have seen them.I had been looking forward to seeing this ship as have never seen a Silversea ship, it had been booked for a few weeks and I made my arrangements at home ...

Read More

May 25 2017 10:26:25:000AM