Cruise Search


Search
Neil and Ida Down - Answered a Question by Smith (29 Dec 07 20:59)

Prices on most other cruise lines are kept lower by the tipping system. If you want there to be no tips then you will have to pay a higher initial. The shipping companies insist that by using the tipping system it encourages the staff to give an exemplary service and we have found that the service is extremely good but wish that the gratuities didn't have to be paid. The fact is though that they do unless you want to penalise someone who gets little or nothing other than the tips you pay. They are not high really but can be grudgingly paid by those who are not au fait with the situation. If the system is to be changed it should be by a concerted effort by us writing to the cruise lines and not penalising the guys and gals who are hoping to send much of the well earned money back to their families. We are sure that some people will disagree with paying tips and write in to say so and there are many who will think up various excuses which they say are valid reasons for not paying them but as we said it will not change a jot except to make deserving workers poorer. ......Neil and Ida .

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
morris - Answered a Question by Smith (29 Dec 07 22:37)

It is interesting to note that the happiest, most polite and hardest working crew members we have encountered have been on the Thomson ships where the gratuities are included in the price of the cruise (probably one of the cheapest cruise companies around)! If Thomson can do it so can all the others and it would save all the arguments about whether tips should be paid or not (or even compulsory as they are on Costa!) Why not just include gratuities in the price of the cruise and be done with it and if you want to add to it you can...

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Ross - Answered a Question by Smith (30 Dec 07 10:38)

Don't go there - this is the most immotive subject on this [and other] boards......I personally pay the tips upfront in the cruise price on RCI or Celebrity, on NCL the tips are added to your account on a daily basis, or I cruise on lines where tipping is neither required or expected. I dislike the whole concept of playing Lady Bountiful walking round handing out wads of cash to people - it just isn't British. Tipping however is built into the American culture and they appear to tip anyone that moves....Personally I wish they would build the cost of the tips into the cruise price and do away with it. That is just MHO. But whatever you do, if tipping is expected then please tip at least the recommended ammount. The staff are paid approx $50pm and they do literally live off their tips. Do not penalise these people just because you may disagree with the concept of tipping.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Neil and Ida Down - Answered a Question by Smith (30 Dec 07 11:25)

Well said Albert (Albertine) and welcome back....Nei.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Wilba - Answered a Question by Smith (31 Dec 07 13:37)

Tipping is at your own discretion whichever Cruise Line you choose, If you don't agree with the autotip then simply remove it at the pursers desk. I'm with most Brits who say build it into the price.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
morris - Answered a Question by Smith (31 Dec 07 15:46)

Costa have 'compulsory' tipping! as far as I know they are the only ones who do this....it is not possible to remove or reduce it so why on earth do they not factor it into the price.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Johnstone - Answered a Question by Smith (31 Dec 07 16:11)

I really don't have a problem with tipping. I find the service on cruise lines so superior to anything you receive on land , so I never grudge it. My preference is to have the preset tip removed from my account and give cash to the staff who have provided the best service to me during my cruise. If it was built in to the price and the crew received better remuneration as a result, it may be preferrable. However I probably still would tip over and above this to anyone I thought was doing a great job.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Wilba - Answered a Question by Smith (31 Dec 07 16:19)

I would like to read Costa's Full terms & Conditions as Service cannot be guaranteed by anyone. NCL have implemented this 'Service Charge' Non removable, but when you read further into their T&C it may be adjusted or removed in the event of a dispute. Service charge has no legal standing in the UK so their product could be breach of UK law if they sell their product here.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Higham - Answered a Question by Smith (05 Jan 08 15:31)

We prefer the tips to be included in the cost of the cruise. This cuts out all the difficulty of knowing how much to tip and it doesn't leave out the workers whom one has no contact with (presumably) .

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report
Beeton - Answered a Question by Smith (07 Jan 08 12:57)

I believe in tipping for a job well done. I do not like the tips to be taken from my card. I have no idea then who gets what, and perhaps I am being cynical, but I have a feeling that the people who work the hardest are given the least, this seems to be the way of the world. I always remove the tipping " Option" from the card, and give to those I am in contact with. The cabin staff especially as they seem to be on duty such long hours, and work very hard indeed..It canot be easy to keep smiling all day long, but somehow they do.

- Was this comment useful or 0 of 0 found this useful
Comment | Report

Daily Top 10 Deals

Show More Deals

Newest Topics

World's Leading Cruise Travel Agent 2016

Mrs M -


Jabs

carol, welwyn garden city -


My third blast at words

Neil Down, Southampton -


My second blast at words….

Neil Down, Southampton -


I would, most certainly, if I could

Neil Down, Southampton -


More

Hot Topics

Richmond Park by-election.

jc, liverpool -


Boored pensioner wants a job.

Old Sea Dog, Stockport -


Jabs

carol, welwyn garden city -


I would, most certainly, if I could

Neil Down, Southampton -


My third blast at words

Neil Down, Southampton -


More
View More From The Forum
Alana Mills's blog

Mysterious Myth or Superstitio...

By Alana Mills

Ahoy there!Sailors over the years have had many superstitions that they believed in. It is no wonder if you think about it as they navigated around the world with no satellites or ship to shore in-case of an emergency. Also, bear in mind as going to sea is one of the worlds oldest occupations, the time these myths were established, it is only natural that where inexplicable events have occurred, superstition and myth have played a major role in providing reasons for their occurrence.So here ...

Read More

Dec 02 2016 08:00AM


My first Transatlantic.

By Steve Fuller

Steve Fuller's blog

I’ve just returned from my first transatlantic cruise. I’ve always wanted to sail into the U.S.A and fly home. To say I’ve been and seen my friends across the pond without flying. I have to say i did really enjoy it. I very much liked the ship. There were a couple of hiccups and if I’m honest I probably wouldn’t do a transatlantic again but I’ve ticked it off. Thais why you have a bucket list to do what you want to do and tick it off the list.It had been 10...

Read More

Nov 30 2016 05:41PM

Naples a great port to visit

By Shirley McCue

Shirley McCue's blog

 I remember my experience of returning to Naples as a cruise passenger with fond memories. Most passengers were eager to scramble into coaches that would whisk them away to see the fascinating ruins of Pompeii or drive down to the winding roads of the Amalfi coast on their journey to Sorrento. This was not my plan as I wanted my family to experience some of my childhood memories. Naples is a large city steeped in history with lots of hidden treasures, some a little too far to venture to ...

Read More

Dec 01 2016 10:29PM